Skip to content
BOGOEvery Door Direct Mail postcards from 2,500 for $349. Buy one, get one on every order. 7am–7pm ET, 7 days a week
November 17, 2026 · 7 min read · Super Cheap Cards

How often should you mail a shared 9×12 postcard?

How often should you mail a shared 9×12 postcard?

The short answer: about every six weeks

If you run a shared postcard or a community card, the question comes up before the first one even prints. Monthly or quarterly? The honest answer depends on where you are, and the right rhythm in year one is very different from the right rhythm in year three.

When you are starting out, mail as often as you reasonably can, which means roughly once a month. Each card you fill brings in money, puts your name in front of every home on the route and gives local business owners another chance to notice you.

Once the card is established, you have choices. Plenty of long-running publishers drop to a seasonal or quarterly schedule. They earned that option by mailing often in the beginning.

Why faster than monthly backfires

It is tempting to think two cards a month means twice the income. In the same area, it mostly means annoyed readers and nervous advertisers.

Your advertisers run coupons and offers that last 30 to 45 days. People keep a good card on the fridge and use the deal a few weeks later, so a new card every two weeks steps on the last one before it has done its job.

The households matter too. A big 9″ × 12″ card is welcome when it shows up about once a month, and it starts to feel like clutter when it shows up every other week. You want people to think, oh good, the new one is here.

Why monthly turns into six to eight weeks

Plan for monthly and you will land on something closer to every six weeks. Nobody tells you this at the start, and it changes your money math.

Artwork takes time. One advertiser out of fifteen goes quiet on their proof approval for four days, a weekend gets in the way, then the post office drop lands on a Friday and slips to Monday. Each delay is small, and together they push a monthly plan out by a week or two.

So be realistic in your forecasts. Six to eight cards in your first twelve months is a strong, consistent year. Build your budget on that number, not on twelve.

Why quarterly is a trap in year one

Quarterly looks easier. One card each season, more time between deadlines, less chasing artwork. Successful publishers mailing tens of thousands of cards across several areas every quarter make it look like the smart way to run things.

Those publishers did not start that way. They started with one card in one area, mailed it again and again, and built a list of advertisers who renew without being asked. Copying their schedule without their history skips the part that made it work.

Starting quarterly causes three problems:

  • You lose touch with advertisers between cards, so every card means selling from scratch again.
  • Homes see the card three or four times a year, which is not enough for it to become a local habit.
  • Someone else can walk into your area, promise a monthly card and take your advertisers.

Frequency is what turns a postcard into a platform

A card that lands every few weeks becomes a local fixture. People share it, mention it to friends and start to expect it. That is the point where it stops being a mailer and becomes an advertising platform.

You can feel the change when business owners start calling you. They saw a competitor on the card, or they noticed there is no pool company on it yet, and they want the spot. Selling gets much easier when the card does the introducing.

After eight to twelve months of steady mailing, a realistic goal is fifty to a hundred businesses that have advertised at least once. With that list, filling a card means finding three or four new names, not fifteen. When you are short a spot or two, your regular advertisers will often point you to someone.

Plan by seasons, not calendar months

Thinking in months sets you up to feel behind. Think in seasons instead, because local buying already follows them and your advertisers plan their offers around them. Most areas give you eight to ten natural moments a year:

  1. New Year
  2. Valentine's Day, or St. Patrick's Day if the timing slips
  3. Early spring
  4. Spring
  5. Summer, which can be hard to fill while owners are on vacation
  6. Early fall, when everything picks up again
  7. Back to school and fall
  8. The holiday run from November into December

Each season gives advertisers an obvious offer to run and gives you a reason to call them. Our seasonal printing calendar lists campaign ideas for each one, which makes handy talking points when you are selling spots.

The card is the front door, not the whole house

Here is the part most new publishers figure out later. Selling ad spots on a shared card has a ceiling, and the publishers who grow past it sell more to the advertisers they already have.

Think of a burger chain, where the burger brings you in and the drinks and fries are where the margin lives. A spot on your card works the same way. A roofer will happily pay a few hundred dollars for a spot, and that small yes opens a relationship you could never start by asking for thousands up front.

Once an advertiser trusts you, offer the work that fits them:

  • Their own EDDM mailing to the neighborhoods they want most
  • Door hangers for a crew working one street at a time
  • Business cards and yard signs for every truck and job site
  • A bigger targeted campaign for high-budget trades such as kitchens, windows or legal services

When most of your profit comes from that work, the card becomes your best lead source. Some publishers go further and price spots low to keep competitors out, because the relationship is worth more than the spot.

Grow deeper before you grow wider

The obvious way to scale is more cities and more cards. It works for a while, then the logistics take over: artwork from forty businesses, billing, collections, proofs, drop dates. Soon you need assistants, a bookkeeper and a salesperson, and you have swapped a boss for a payroll.

The simpler path is to fill one area well, mail it on a steady rhythm and sell more to each advertiser. Add a new area when the first one nearly runs itself, not before.

If you do run several areas, price them together. Send your list of routes and quantities through our price match and bulk page and we will quote the whole run with shipping.

What the printing costs

A 9″ × 12″ card on thick 16pt stock is the classic size for shared mailers, because it gives each advertiser room and stands out in the mailbox. It also qualifies for EDDM, so the post office delivers it to every home on the routes you pick without a mailing list.

With our buy-one-get-one pricing, 2,500 cards cost $579, 5,000 cost $869 and 10,000 cost $1,489. See every option on the 9×12 postcard page, and work out postage for your routes with the EDDM cost calculator.

Planning your first card or switching printers mid-season? Call Corey at 512-573-1977, 7am to 7pm Eastern, and he will price your next run while you are on the phone.

Quick answers

Is monthly or quarterly better for a community card?

In your first year, monthly, which really means every six to eight weeks. Quarterly works later, once advertisers renew on their own and homes recognize the card.

How many shared postcards should I mail in my first year?

Six to eight is a realistic and strong target. Delays with artwork, approvals and drop dates stretch a monthly plan, so build your budget on that number.

Can a 9×12 shared postcard go out with EDDM?

Yes. EDDM accepts flats up to 12 inches high and 15 inches long, so a 9″ × 12″ card qualifies. Keep the top right of the address side clear for the indicia.

Should I add more cities or more cards per city?

Fill one area well first. More cities bring more artwork, billing and staff, while selling more to your existing advertisers grows income without the extra work.

Ready to order?Price your postcards
Callers get the best deal

Call for a better price.

Tell us what you want printed and how many. Corey answers, prices your exact order and can often find a discount the website does not show.

Corey, owner of Super Cheap Cards Corey answers. He owns the company. Call now, 7 days a week 512-573-1977 7am–7pm ET, 7 days a week Call 512-573-1977
Call 512-573-1977 Get a quote
Free quote